Sill Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Sill Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent near Fort Sill courtesy of Military Real Estate!

breast feeding in public...

who's talking here?

Sharon 6
tish 4
Reality Sinks In 23
Penelope 8
mommyof2 9
Victoria1 1
Iamcleaningouthouse 8
Sweet 2
Just sayin' 1
TexasChild 1
Madison's Mommy and Joe's Baby 3
Bologna 1
Tatjana 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

mommyof2 --- 16 years ago -

ok, so i was on cafemoms and read a story about how a woman was kicked out of a country buffet for breast feeding. i guess she wasn't covering up and people were getting offended. anyways, i'm just wondering what other people think about breast feeding in public. i am totally for it, as i bf my daughter. i do cover up, but that's hard to do sometimes b/c as other breast feeding moms know, not all babies like to be covered up with a blanket...they want to look into our eyes, and i want to watch my daughter also! it's also harder to get them to latch under a blanket. but i do my best when i do have to whip it out! i've had people tell me they are offended by me feeding her in public...my response has lately been, well i'm offended by your eating, so please put a blanket over your head so i don't have to see. i even offered a blanket to someone once! it's my daughters only source of food, as i will not buy formula. we have one can for emergency situations only where i am just absolutely unable to bf her. that can has only been used once! there are even state laws stating that i have the right to feed her anywhere and anytime. some states even exempt a mother from indecent exposure if her nipple and/or breast is exposed during nursing. anyways, what are your thoughts? sorry, just thinking today and wondering what everyone else thinks...sorry if it's weird!!! 

Sharon --- 16 years ago -

I think that as long as you are trying to keep it between you and her it is fine. I BF in public when I had to. should we have to stay home just because a feeding might come up? Heck no. It is the natural way of feeding a baby and america has gotten away from it. I always had a blanket ready and if they did not want it on them I still had it around them so that it was not just all out there, but that was my own thing. It was for no one but me. 

TexasChild --- 16 years ago -

I agree w/ both of yall. Though it was uncomfortable for me to do it in public & I would take extra steps to prevent her from needing a feeding while I was out, if she got hungry I would feed her. Someone once asked me to go in the bathroom "for privacy". I went off!! Why should me & my daughter have to go into a filthy, germ filled, smelly bathroom for my daughter to eat!? Sad part is that most of the people saying something negative were prolly BF themselves! Formula was'nt as widely used 30+ years ago as it is now! My thing is, If you don't wanna see, don't look!! This subject REALLY makes me mad. 

Tatjana --- 16 years ago -

I think its really good that this subject came up. I think its ridiculous when people come over and say they are bothered by you feeding your child. Im from Germany and there this subject doesnt even come up at all cuz everybody thinks that its great if a mom breastfeeds her baby and that it is something natural. So for me its unbelieveable how dumb people can be. I had a lil girl 4 weeks ago and i bf her too, also in public. I cover up but hey if it shows a little when i latch her on or take her off i dont care. Im not trying to get some persons attention when i bf so why would they be offended. I think the people that are offended by something like this are sick in their head cuz they are the ones who are making up the wrong things in their mind, if you know what i mean. Yea and i also think if they dont wanna see it they shouldnt put there eyeballs there. Gosh, really i cant go to somebody either and say hey get surgery cuz your face offends me or can i know? So everybody who has a problem with a mom bf her baby should just go ahead and get their thinking great cuz this is the most natural thing ever. 

Madison's Mommy and Joe's Baby --- 16 years ago -

I used to bf my daughter, and i would feed her when she was hungry no matter where we were. Unfortunately due to my own medical problems i stopped producing milk at 2 weeks and was forced to formula feed. it breaks my heart but I support all bfing moms. its amazing how ppl can support vulgar PDA but not bfing. 

mommyof2 --- 16 years ago -

they are having a nurse in at the old country buffet in minnesota (i think that's the state, i'll check and correct if need be...) b/c of what happened to this chick last week...would anyone else be interested in doing something like that to promote breastfeeding? 

Madison's Mommy and Joe's Baby --- 16 years ago -

I think that is a great idea mommy 

Sharon --- 16 years ago -

Check with the WIC office, they might head it up. They have BF interns and nurses that help moms with BF trouble to try to get them to be able to continue with BF'ing. That might be right up their alley. 

Sweet --- 16 years ago -

 

Sweet --- 16 years ago -

yeah that or nurse jackie the lactation consaultant at ccmh shes on the maternity ward she really great if u need books or anything to with nurseing she the one to ask she was so helpful for me 

mommyof2 --- 16 years ago -

i am pretty sure the first week of may is breastfeeding awareness week...it may be a different week, but i'm pretty sure that's the day. what would yall think of meeting at a park on a saturday and having a picnic with our families? those of us who bf can do so publicly, but not make a huge deal about it...just to show that we are proud bf-ers! sharon, i'll call wic monday morning to see what they think and if they would be willing to support us in that. because of their jobs at wic, they may not be able to do something like that for legal reasons...it could put their jobs in jeopardy if this became really public, and i wouldn't want to be responsible for a lost job, but i'll still ask!!! thanks for the idea, i would have never thought of it!! 

tish --- 16 years ago -

i am glad to hear of your support for bfing, all of you. many thanks. i myself was asked to leave applebee's many many years ago when i was really young, first time mom and going through the what-in-the-world's of bfing. i was in tears by the time i hit the door to leave, it was very humiliating, but back then they didn't have the bills in place to protect bfing moms as they do today. i think that is wonderful what ya'll are doing to promote it. i don't know if you ever heard of that one lady who got asked to get off of a certain plane because of bfing her son, and she ended up rounding up her girls and lots of others showed up to bf in the waiting area of that airline!!!! mommyof2,if you don't mind, i would like to contact my friend at a wic office there in lawton, i know she would so be up for this!!! let me know... 

Madison's Mommy and Joe's Baby --- 16 years ago -

Im all for helping in any way I can, and would love to get together with other moms. Idk anyone in Lawton, other than family and co-workers. 

Penelope --- 16 years ago -

Hi everybody! I am currently a Breastfeeding Peer Counselor for WCD/WIC. I have 5 kids and breastfed each and every one of them. I breastfed whenever or wherever the moment called for it. If my baby was hungry when I was grocery shopping then you would find me walking down the aisle with a blanket over my shoulder. Oklahoma Law: 2004 Mothers have the right to breastfeed anywhere they have a right to be, and shall be excused from jury duty upon request. HB 2102 2006 Breastfeeding mothers may use unpaid break and meal times to breastfeed or express breastmilk at work. Employers are urged to provide a private area (other than a toilet stall) for this purpose. HB 2358 I really like the idea of a public display of breastfeeding and would love to have pictures for my wall or to show other mom's that it can be done. If somebody is planning on organizing a "Public Display" please let me know! penypitstop@yahoo.com Thanks, Penny 

Penelope --- 16 years ago -

Hi everybody! I am currently a Breastfeeding Peer Counselor for WCD/WIC. I have 5 kids and breastfed each and every one of them. I breastfed whenever or wherever the moment called for it. If my baby was hungry when I was grocery shopping then you would find me walking down the aisle with a blanket over my shoulder. Oklahoma Law: 2004 Mothers have the right to breastfeed anywhere they have a right to be, and shall be excused from jury duty upon request. HB 2102 2006 Breastfeeding mothers may use unpaid break and meal times to breastfeed or express breastmilk at work. Employers are urged to provide a private area (other than a toilet stall) for this purpose. HB 2358 I really like the idea of a public display of breastfeeding and would love to have pictures for my wall or to show other mom's that it can be done. If somebody is planning on organizing a "Public Display" please let me know! penypitstop@yahoo.com Thanks, Penny 

Penelope --- 16 years ago -

OK, now I really want to organize this thing. I found out the Arts Festival is the second weekend in May which also happens to be mother's day weekend. I called the committee about staging a "nurse-in" more for photographical reasons than anything else. She said, "Breastfeeding is a great thing, and I deffinitely think women should have a place to do it..." I say lets go for it. Would be a great stand for breastfeeders and also empower our young mothers for mother's day... I have to talk to my supervisor and see if she has any suggestions but I feel as if I am going full tilt on this! How dare she, she told me she doesn't think this is "the right kind of thing for the arts festival". Even after I told her it was for pictures which is catagorized as arts. Anyway, contact me at penypitstop@yahoo.com penny 

Sharon --- 16 years ago -

Way to go gals. Unfortunately I do not BF anymore, but I think it is great to take a stand on something so important. I stopped producing milk and had to make a choice to stop so I could feed my twins enough to survive. I had the same problem with my older ones, but always BF them until that occured. Figured I would do it as long as I could to give them the very best. 

Reality Sinks In --- 16 years ago -

I'm all for breastfeeding BUT...BF should be something one HAS to do in public and not something one goes out of their way to do because you want to public display. ???? That's the same concept of on purposely going outside to pee in front of everyone at a park, even though it's not widely accepted IN the USA, but is occassionally a have to. UMM yes I know that's acceptable in Germany too. So is not taking a bath regularly to conserve water and wearing your clothes more than one day, and hanging your undergarmets outside to dry for all neighbors to see ..... 

tish --- 16 years ago -

i feel the same way but about women showing TOO much cleavage and with the ripped pants right at their crotches or in the rear end, or when they wear the over-exposed bikinis, is it really necessary for them to go so much out of their way to publicly display what everyone already knows is there, but many (well except for men of course)don't care to see. i would say its the same concepts, turns heads just like bfing does, with the exception that bfing used to be the norm back in the days, back then there wasn't the luxury of optional feeding methods, it was bfing or a wet nurse. either way shows how our world has evolved.......its not ok for a woman to feed her baby in public but its ok for one to go out and "display" herself to the point to where she doesnt leave much to the imagination.....so i guess it would be ok for her to dress that way around her child (i.e. thong swimsuit, see-thru shirts, or ta-ta's coming out the top shirts.....) just my own opinion, not intended to rouse anyone up.... 

tish --- 16 years ago -

oh hi penny!!!! yup that's my girl i was talking about!! 

Reality Sinks In --- 16 years ago -

Agreed Tish. Except it's not ok for one to "display" themselves in a thong bikini etc., but it doesn't mean we all have to go out and do it just to make an awareness of it either. 

Penelope --- 16 years ago -

well RSI your comparison certainly shows which side of BF in public you are on. I don't see how you can compare breastfeeding in public to peeing in public. There just is no comparison. I am trying to raise awareness that it is ok for mothers to breastfeed in public. What a mother does when she is breastfeeding her baby is so much more than just a show, and there are so many ways it can be done discreetly, or not, that is the mother's choice, and if she has to sit and worry about what some pervert is thinking or some other mother worried about kids pointing or laughing. If it was done more then it would be the norm and I don't see any reason it should be otherwise. ...and anyway, I don't need the committee approval for a nurse-in, just the mamas and the babies. It is the law, any mother can feed her baby wherever she is allowed to be. I would like every breastfeeding mother to feel pride when her baby is hungry, and not shame. Penny 

Tatjana --- 16 years ago -

reality sinks in: i dont know where you lived in germany, but where im from we use dryers except for grandmas so thats probably who you lived next to. Also ( not to offend anybody )since i came here, to the south of the states i got a complete culture shock! U think germans / Europeans dont bath? No your right we dont, we shower cuz we dont like sitting in our own dirt. And also i have never seen houses as dirty as here in my whole life! In germany your landlord would kick you out if you would mess his house up like that.Not to get me wrong, im not saying everybody is dirty here im just saying if you see the houses of the 'not too clean people' here compared to the 'not too clean people' there, its a huge difference. And also I dont think any breastfeeding mom rather breastfeeds in public than at home or has in her mind 'hey im gonna breastfeed now cuz i wanna publicly display',but they/we dont lock us up in the house all day so if we dont wanna let our baby cry til we get home, we have to feed him/her in public. And anyway everybody normally covers up to the best of their ability so wheres the big problem? 

Iamcleaningouthouse --- 16 years ago -

RSI...BF should be something one HAS to do in public and not something one goes out of their way to do because you want to public display. ???? For all of you that dont know AWARENESS is to have knowledge of something by having observed it. So how could they have an awareness day for breastfeeding without out purposely going out and having a public display of breast feeding. i dont breast feed but I dont have a problem with women that do and I dont get uncomfortable with it either. The problem is that everyone just has too much of an opinion about what everyone else does. You think you have the right to say what you think about everything that other people do but you dont. what they do is there business, especially since oklahoma laws are one of the strongest and most enforced you will ever find in comparison to any other state. If you dont like to see a mom breastfeeding then dont look I mean we all have control over our wondering eyes. A women should breast feed in public only if she has to sounds like your suggesting other measures and precautions should be taken before you resort to BFing which is bull$hit. You should not have to work your schedule around your babies feeding time. you should continue with your schedule as normal and feed your child as you normally do at the normal times. Cover up if you want to or dont its up to you. people should really grow up I mean asking a women to leave applebees or giving the dirty eye.. just rediculous... Who the he!! says you have to look there way anyway. there should be an awareness day where all you bfing moms go out there and make everyone aware that women are still bfing and we will continue to do so as we please. 

Tatjana --- 16 years ago -

completely agree, couldnt have said it better! 

Reality Sinks In --- 16 years ago -

Tatjana, I might have. I just know it was very normal to walk outside and see Texas sized underwear and bras on the lines. Wasn't offended, but was kinda humerous. Not something I'd be caught doing. Penny--I think you only read what you wanted to. I am for breastfeeding. Think it's great!! Did my two boys. But not once do I remember Having to do it in public. No I didn't let them cry. They ate every two hours. Plenty of time to do what I need and go back home or if case be borrow a bedroom at the house I was in. Could you imagine being at a couple's house and say tough I'm nursing in your living room vs. a bedroom?? Or working in the hospital and pumping your breast while at the nurses station?? No they provide rooms for that. How is peeing in public not a comparison? Dogs do it so why shouldn't expelling ourselves in public be sooo much more than a show? Running around nude is natural too and should be embraced afterall bare skin was back in the day too. You should organize that type of display too. People know it's ok if you HAVE to publicly breastfeed. One little "show" is not going to raise any awareness to the world. Everyone already has an opinion and if they do it, so be it. But to get a group of women together just cuz it's "the law" and whip out tits is not going to change anyone's opinions. Let's face it the world is evolving and what was acceptable "back in the day" doesn't have to be acceptable now. I'm not saying end breast feeding, but one doesn't have to do it infront of the world. Geesh. A wise person once told me... "Somethings are better done in private" 

Reality Sinks In --- 16 years ago -

Iamcleaningoutthehouse- Giving out pamplets and stickers to new moms also raises awareness. I think everyone has the right to say what they think. Afterall doing a "public display" is an opinion, otherwise the thread wouldn't have been started. There's always two sides to a coin. Not one. Working around schedules is a part of everyday life. So don't make an excuse. We all have control over our wandering eyes just as well as a breastfeeding mom has a choice of where it's proper to nurse. Who wants to eat dinner in a resturant when a mom who choses not to cover up is breastfeeding? That's what they make pumps for!! 

Iamcleaningouthouse --- 16 years ago -

You know RSI you have to be the most biggest hypocritical no sense making moron. your whole comment pissed me off but not because of your opinion but because of the ignorant way you expressed it. You say that you are all for breastfeeding but just not in public. hey its great you never had to do anything that took more than 2 hours guess you dint have much of a life. As for the mommys that do its not a easy as going back home everytime its feeding time. yes in hospitals they have private rooms and yes in a friends house they do have private rooms but how about in a restaurant. they DO NOT have private rooms. And Im sorry no women should have to breast feed her baby in a bathroom. Most of ud dont even want to go pee in a public bathroom much less have to feed a baby in there. If everyone else doesnt have to eat there meals in a bathroom stall then neither should a baby. Also if I dont want to go to a private room I shouldnt have to. the law states I can breast feed anywhere I have the right to be, If your in a friends house ask ifyou can breast feed and cover up right there if they dont mind do your thing. In a public place dont search for privacy do it right where you are. A women shouldnt be forced to seek cover to feed her baby. After all you eat in public with your horse chewing A$$ and no one asks you to get a room and Im sure you public kiss your man if you have one and no one says get a room so they shouldnt have to either. You seem to have all the answers to not having to breastfeed in public but yet your mind is so limited. No all places have a public place to resort to. What if we go to the park where's the privacy there.. NO WHERE.. so breast feeding in public is necessary. Not all women want to be trapped in there home just to provide there babies with a nutritous meal every two hours.. when nutritous meals can be provided anywhere. and not every women is at home as much as you were many of us do have exciting lives. How do you know one little show is not going to raise any awareness. In case you werent aware this is how breats cancer awareness began with just one small awareness group which eventually grew to as we know it today. Closed minded thinking like yours is what keeps us behind in society. Everything big started from somewhere small. This awareness meeting may grow into something huge with time and owrk and supporters. Also peeing in public is not the same as breast feeding and the fact that you keep bringing it up in comaprison juts shows the level of ignornace you do possess. peeing in public is not acceptable because for one its unsanitary to just pee on public ground where dogs, kids and adults will be walking and it will make the streets smell really badly. thats why although its natural its not accepted. breast feeding in public does not cause any harm to the environment and it does not smell theonly problem with breastfeeding is that everyone has an opinion and they swear it always has to be heard. Its funny because the people that laways have a problem with breast feeding ar ethe ones who always have there back turned to stare. When in reality if you just minded your business you would never even know it was going on rightbehind you. Also it is not the same as public nudity. For one breast feeder cover you I have never seen a women just whip it out with out some grace and cover. breastf feeding is occuring under a blanket and the quick flesh dislplay may occur for just a second. Walking around naked is different its public nudity without the intent to cover up and its not peforming any important task such as providing nutrition to the hungry. That person told you 'somethings are better left in private" and that was wise but did they mention that they meant it for your opinions as well. 

Reality Sinks In --- 16 years ago -

"having no life"... U sure you don't know lindsey? Gonna turn me into the cops for having an opinion too? It's called organized. I am extremely organized so I managed and never had to breastfeed in public. Some places shouldn't be nursed in. I don't know like a resturant where people are trying to eat. You see smacking as gross. Close your damn ears then. U make no sense. You make it sound like whipping a tit out is the only way to give a baby nutritious meals. Hello!!!!! Pumps. The world has evolved and there is this great invention called breast pumps. Wow!! Now who's behind in society? Funny how one can criticise a person for stating their opinions when infact they're doing the same thing. HMMM 

Iamcleaningouthouse --- 16 years ago -

WHo wants to eat in a restaurant when a mother is breastfeeding!?! oh please there is nothing wrong with a breast feeding mom in a restaurant its only a problem when limited thinking and problematic people make it one. I dont like eating in a restaurant when people chew like cows or talkw ith there mouth full next to me or have there babies crying so loud I cant think or have there kids running around throwing stuff or have a women with half her clothes missing but I do anyway. Should we start asking everyone that does something that bothers us in a restautant to leave. Women dont have a choice on w here its proper to nurse the law makes that choice for us and luckily oklahoma says its cool to BF in a restautant. Also we dont have control over our babies eating schedules when they are hungry they are hungry thats that. ALSO YOUR BABY IS NOT A SCHEDULE THAT YOU WORK AROUND. A BABY IS NOT A JOB THEY ARE A SMALL PERSON. a public display is also not an opinion, an opinion is anopinion and a public display is relating to ior concerning people in a large group and it also means to involve the government and state agencies. A public display is not an opinion its an expression of an opinion. Its a way we choose to share our opinions with others and to get others to join us. an opinon is just a simple view based on personal judgement alone. You also keep saying public display as if everyone said oh lets go take off our bras that week all they said was breats feed altogether in a group. Your right everyone is entitled to an opinon but yours is hypocritical its ok to breastfeed as long as you do all you can to keep it at home. yes there are two sides to every coin but the coin still has the same value regardless of which side it falls on. The law states it can be done publicly if you dont like it then maybe you should petition the state to change its law. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Sill Underground